How to Get Reviews for a Self-Published Picture Book (Without Breaking the Rules)
Share
Reviews matter for picture books, but not in the way most marketing advice suggests. A parent scrolling Amazon at 10pm wants a quick signal that real families enjoyed your book. A school librarian wants to know it reads aloud well. A bookstagrammer wants to know it's worth a post. This guide shows you how to get honest reviews from each of those groups, without paying for them or bending the rules.
First, know the rules
Amazon's customer review guidelines don't allow reviews in exchange for payment, gifts or favors. The one exception that matters to authors: you can give free or discounted copies of your book to readers, as long as you don't require a review in return and don't try to influence what they say. So your wording should always be "if you'd like to share an honest review, it would really help" and never "in exchange for a review."
A few other things to avoid:
- Asking close family or friends to post reviews (Amazon may remove them).
- Review swaps with other authors.
- Asking only people you know will leave five stars.
- Services that promise a set number of reviews.
Keep it simple: put the book in front of the right readers, make reviewing easy, and let them say what they think.
Step 1: Build an early reader list (6–8 weeks before launch)
Your best early reviewers are people who read picture books aloud often: parents of 3–7 year olds, preschool and elementary teachers, librarians, homeschool families and grandparents. Aim for 20–40 people, because not everyone who receives a copy will review.
Where to find them:
- Your email list and your free checklist sign-ups.
- Parents you've met at school visits, story times and markets.
- Teacher and homeschool groups you're already part of (follow each group's self-promotion rules).
- Readers who've commented on your posts about the book.
Send a short, friendly invitation: what the book is about, the age range, the publication date, and how they'll receive it (PDF, printed proof or finished copy). Make it clear that reviewing is optional.
Step 2: Make it easy to review on launch day
Most people who mean to review simply forget. On publication day, send one email with:
- A direct link to the book's Amazon page (and Goodreads, if you use it).
- A reminder that one or two honest sentences is plenty.
- A gentle prompt for what's useful to other parents: the age their child is, whether it worked as a bedtime read, what their child said or asked.
Follow up once, about a week later. Then stop. Repeated chasing loses goodwill.
Step 3: Reach bookstagrammers and kidlit creators
For picture books, a photo of a real child holding your book often does more than a written review. Look for Instagram and TikTok accounts that regularly feature picture books for your age range, have engaged comments (not just big follower counts), and post books similar to yours.
Write a personal message for each one. Mention a recent post you liked, explain in a sentence why your book fits their audience, and ask if they'd like a copy with no obligation to post. Keep a simple tracker of who you contacted, when, and what happened, so you don't double-message anyone.
Step 4: Ask teachers and librarians the right way
Educators rarely leave Amazon reviews, but their opinion carries real weight. After a school visit or library story time, ask if they'd be willing to share a sentence about how the book worked with their class. With permission, you can quote it (with their role, and their name only if they're happy) on your website, your school visit menu and your Amazon A+ Content.
This kind of endorsement is especially useful when you pitch the next school, because it answers the question every teacher has: "Will this work with my kids?"
Step 5: Decide on editorial reviews
Major trade review journals review relatively few self-published titles. Some outlets offer paid review programs for independent authors. These can produce a quotable line for your cover or product page, but they don't guarantee a positive review or extra sales. Treat them as an optional extra once your launch plan is in place, not a substitute for reader reviews.
Step 6: Keep reviews coming after launch
- Add a short, friendly note on your website and in your newsletter inviting readers to share an honest review.
- After each school visit, include the review link in the thank-you email to the teacher, alongside any parent order details.
- Reshare reviews and reader photos (with permission). It reminds other readers that reviewing is normal.
How the Picture Book Launch Kit helps
The Picture Book Launch Kit turns this plan into fill-in templates, so you're not writing every message from scratch:
- Early Reader Invitation: a ready-to-adapt message for recruiting your early reader list, with rule-safe wording.
- Bookstagrammer Outreach: a personal pitch structure for creators, plus what to include with a copy.
- Outreach Tracker: one place to log every reader, creator and educator you contact.
- Launch Week Checklist and 90-Day Calendar: so the review requests land at the right moment, not as an afterthought.
It's a 47-page PDF with 18 templates and a UK & US edition. See what's inside the Launch Kit.
Not ready yet? Start with the free Picture Book Launch Checklist, which shows where reviews fit into your launch timeline.
